Brief observations about articles, movies, and details about academic life. This blog attempts to determine the connections between what seems to be random and articulates how ideas, issues, or events intersect.
Thursday, February 10, 2011
Pop Culture Fiction
When Emily posted something about guilty pleasures, I remembered a post I had drafted about my guilty reading pleasures but didn't finish. As an English professor, I always feel the need to read the classics. Really, what kind of Victorian literature scholar am I if I haven't read every Charles Dickens novel (note to take Martin Chezzlewit off my bookshelf this week) but every now and then I like to delve into the popular fiction. My most recent guilty pleasure is the Girl with the Dragon Tatoo series by Stieg Larsson, a Swedish author. I've finished two of the three books so far and am anxious to start the third and final book. The story takes place in Sweden and switches between the perspectives between a journalist, who exposes economic scandals, and an alienated young computer hacker, Lisbeth Salander who is independent, brilliant, and strong but refuses to let anyone get close to her. The two work together on the case of a young woman who disappeared 40 years earlier. After working on that case together (note that I don't want to discuss that storyline too much), they go their separate ways but always seem to connect later on. While Larsson writes engaging an storyline, I'm troubled by his preoccupation of the mistreatment of women, mistreatment by their fathers, their brothers, their significant others, their guardians, the people that are supposed to keep them safe. In fact, there are not a lot of likable men in the series due to the graphic descriptions of abuses of women. Which makes me wonder - why present such mistreatment in the novels? Is Larsson trying to expose the amount of abuse that does occur? Is he trying to articulate a way to solve the problems? I'm interested to see how he'll wrap up the trilogy. Will Salandar get revenge on the men who have harmed her? Will she change to allow people in her life? She'd lose the air of mystery and defiance that defines who she is. And what does that mean if she does change?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I don't think you have to consider contemporary novels as guilty pleasures. Of course, as scholars you are expected to read the classics and the authors who helped to shape literature as we know it. However, we shouldn't forget about new authors breaking into the literary world. There are still genres to develop, literary devices to experiment with, so we should not pass these contemporary novels aside because they are mainstream. Sorry, I went on a rant. P.S. I still have not read The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo...that will be a summer project!
ReplyDeleteHey Beck! Thanks for posting. You raise a good point about not writing off mainstream novels. I do think that authors should break through into the literary world and I do appreciate more contemporary authors like Philip Roth and Jhumpa Lahiri. I'm just not sure Larsson series is in the same category as those two authors.
ReplyDelete